Top 5 NFL QB's

[GoldenRamsFAN]

1. Matt Ryan
2. Tom Brady
3. Ben Roethlisberger
4. Aaron Rodgers
5. Derek Carr

Now you did it! Matty Ryan above the winningest QB of all time..hear comes the storm

All time rankings brady is ahead of him no doubt. But this is How i ranked the qbs going into week 2 of the season. If you want an all time top 10 qb list,
1. Brady*** (*** because the cheating that has taken place in the org)
2. Montana
3. Bradshaw
4. Manning
5. Favre

Well, who's your other 5? Lol

[konjo78]

Now you did it! Matty Ryan above the winningest QB of all time..hear comes the storm

All time rankings brady is ahead of him no doubt. But this is How i ranked the qbs going into week 2 of the season. If you want an all time top 10 qb list,
1. Brady*** (*** because the cheating that has taken place in the org)
2. Montana
3. Bradshaw
4. Manning
5. Elway

Well, who's your other 5? Lol

6. Favre
7. Aikman
8. Big ben
9. Steve young
10. Roger staubach

[theoneandonly]

Who is Aiken? 

Big Ben in over some guy named Elway? Might as well stick Kordell up there as well. 

[konjo78]

Who is Aiken? 

Big Ben in over some guy named Elway? Might as well stick Kordell up there as well. 

dang forget elway id but him above Farve and move everyone down 1. I mispelled troy aikman

[EaglealumsGhost]

Well if you mean right now after 1week it's 
1A. Smith
2.m. Stafford 
3 S Bradford 
4 T Siemian 
5 C Wentz 
16 weeks will probably change that haha

[theoneandonly]

Ben doesn't deserve to be anywhere near the top 10 of all time NFL QB. If he is then so is Eli Manning... their stats are very similar (look em up) and both have 2 rings. Do you think Eli is a top 10-15 QB of all time? 
 

Plus Ben is atrocious on the road. Take off the black and gold glasses and be objective. 


Names like Graham, Kelly, Tarkenton, Brees, Rodgers, Starr, Tarkenton, Unitas, and Marino can all be mentioned well before Ben, along with the other more sensible names you listed.

 Realistically he's probably somewhere in the 25ish range. 

[Manfred]

Presume this is for current ones?

Yes, so please keep Ryan Leaf off your list.

Hahaha!  He was right there after Kapernick.

[Manfred]

Ben doesn't deserve to be anywhere near the top 10 of all time NFL QB. If he is then so is Eli Manning... their stats are very similar (look em up) and both have 2 rings. Do you think Eli is a top 10-15 QB of all time? 
 

Plus Ben is atrocious on the road. Take off the black and gold glasses and be objective. 


Names like Graham, Kelly, Tarkenton, Brees, Rodgers, Starr, Tarkenton, Unitas, and Marino can all be mentioned well before Ben, along with the other more sensible names you listed.

 Realistically he's probably somewhere in the 25ish range. 

^^^^This guy gets it.  Toss in a couple more like Dawson, Griese, Stabler, Lamonica, Jurgensen.

[konjo78]

The big difference where ben puts himself a good bit ahead of Eli is in win %, bens is 65% to elis 53%, and in ints, Big ben has 161 to eli's 216.

Ben i feel has earned his spot because of how well he has played throughout his career with a variety of different offensive weapons. Not many qbs can say they are having their best careers while still near the end of their pro play cycle. If he does win a 3rd superbowl he could easily be looked at as a top 5 qb all time.

[theoneandonly]

Top 5? By who? You?

Thats my point... Eli isn't a top 10 of all time and neither is Ben.

Do a google search of "top 10 QB of all time" and you won't find a single mention of his name on any of them...

All QB have a variety of different offensive weapons in their career. Favre, Manning and Brady (just recent guys) all played at a very high level late into their careers. Ben had a HoF WR in Ward, the best WR in the game today in Brown and a very very talented Le'Veon Bell. He's never been short on talent.

Additionally, I don't know that Ben is a top 5 qb of his generation let alone all time. Brady, Brees, Rodgers and Peyton are all ahead of him in every  category that matters statistically. Don't even use rings as a barometer... Marino doesn't have one and Dilfer does. It's irrelevant. 


Anyone that has Bradshaw top 5 and no Elway is instantly discredited... also, JJ Watt is still overrated, right?