Who is the worst starting QB in the NFL?

[fleaflicker]

I too, thought Vinny would get it early on, but he's made a good showing thus far, especially with Keyshawn Johnson. I think Keyshawn and Galloway will be a bit help out to Testeverde, and he's not going to be as bad as Rivers or Brees, Boller, or McCown. And what about the Giants? I don't think the starter there will be the worst, but he will certainly be amoung the worst, unless Warner gets back in Super Bowl form rather than his winless form.

[NbBaseballWG5]

I think that Kurt Warner is over-rated.....by far.....When he was in Super Bowl form....he had some talented receivers....like Torry Holt, Isaac Bruce, Az-Zahir Hakim, etc... I think that is how Marc Bulger is doing well, although the Lions do have Hakim, Bruce and Holt are among the two best wide receivers in the NFL.....Kurt Warner won't be as good as the Super Bowl Kurt Warner.....but he may be able to do something in New York...

[CTtrackster]

You cant really say this qbs bad or that qbs good. When you think about it, The qb can only do so much, you have to look at the talent that surround him. Say Kordell Stewart for example. He does defy my little idea here. He is just plain bad. But some qbs work well in one system while it may not work well for another. Like maddox cant be put into the system that vick is using, for obivous reasons. So you have to judge how well the qb does with what he has to offer. Id say gannon isnt all that hot. He had two incredible recievers in brown and rice. granted they are old but he also has porter, and it wasnt like his backs were terrible either. Both could run pretty good. But he did rather poorly.

[duckb32]

To update some posts in this topic....the Chargers announced yesterday that Drew Brees will be the opeing day starter.

[pizzasagent407]

I would have to say either Josh McCown AZ, Shaun King AZ, or Tim Rattay SF!!!

[fearandloathing]

Sorry fellas but Tommy Maddox or Vinny Testeverde r a toss up between the worst qb's in the NFL. Maddox has the receiving talent in the world and the Steelers still won't make the playoffs. Maybe in Vince McMahon's XFL he was a star, but he will get bodyslammed until Roetheisberger or whatever Mcdonald's name is steps in. The Steelers will suffer and Dallas will have a new qb by week 3. It's all in the age and suffering 4 both of these once Super Bowl opponents. At least Neil O Donnel, gave effort but gave the game 2 Dallas. AHAHAHAH steeler fans hahahah

[Sneakers]

After the early games on Sunday, it just may be Kyle Boller, Baltimore Ravens. What a shame they were only able to put up 3 points against the Browns.....(But knowing my luck, watch this post come back to bite me when they hook up with the Steelers)

[duckb32]

Its early in the season but Brees looked really good today...he might bite me in the rear for this topic...No Maddox isnt the worst QB in the league..hes not the greatest..but theres plenty worse then him..

[NbBaseballWG5]

There is no way Vinny Testaverde can be among the worst QB's in the NFL......he threw for 355 yards today with a TD....and Mark Brunell did pretty bad today.....Kyle Boller as well....hmm...Tim Rattay and Ken Dorsey.....definitely....