Top 5 NFL QB's

[abpk2903]

The Current NFL Starters can be but into these categories rather easily:

-Greats (can take you all the way by themselves): Brady, Rodgers
-Goods (with a little help, can take you all the way): Ryan, Newton, Stafford, Carr, Roethlisberger, Rivers, Wilson
-Serviceables (with a great supporting cast, you can win with them): Palmer, Flacco, Dalton, Smith, Cutler, Bradford, Eli, Cousins
-Can’t win withs: Taylor, Glennon, Tolzien, Bortles, McCown

The rest haven’t been in the league long enough to give a fair assessment either way but I will classify them this way:

-Too new but trending up: Prescott, Wentz, Winston, Mariota, Watson
-Too new but trending down: Goff, Kizer, Siemian

[12HankQB]

The Current NFL Starters can be but into these categories rather easily:

-Greats (can take you all the way by themselves): Brady, Rodgers
-Goods (with a little help, can take you all the way): Ryan, Newton, Stafford, Carr, Roethlisberger, Rivers, Wilson
-Serviceables (with a great supporting cast, you can win with them):  Palmer, Flacco, Dalton, Smith, Cutler, Bradford, Eli, Cousins
-Can’t win withs:  Taylor, Glennon, Tolzien, Bortles, McCown

The rest haven’t been in the league long enough to give a fair assessment either way but I will classify them this way:

-Too new but trending up:  Prescott, Wentz, Winston, Mariota, Watson
-Too new but trending down: Goff, Kizer, Siemian

Rodgers needs to get to the super bowl again. As far as current this year, i like your list. 

[GoldenRamsFAN]

For everyone so high on Rodgers every year he seems to choke in the playoffs a lot.

[abpk2903]

He has carried the Packers deep into the playoffs multiple times with holes all through that roster.  One year he would do it with a defense ranked in the bottom third of the league, another year the offensive line play is atrocious, another year their receiving corps literally all injured, and heck last year they went to the NFC Championship game using a WR as their "go-to" RB.  That team would have been lucky to average 7 wins a year over the last decade without Rodgers.

[12HankQB]

Matt Ryan played the same choke tune. Dominated through regular season then choked in the playoffs...until he finally made the super bowl..and choked the hardest choke that ever choked

[konjo78]

1. Matt Ryan
2. Tom Brady
3. Ben Roethlisberger
4. Aaron Rodgers
5. Derek Carr

[12HankQB]

1. Matt Ryan
2. Tom Brady
3. Ben Roethlisberger
4. Aaron Rodgers
5. Derek Carr

Now you did it! Matty Ryan above the winningest QB of all time..hear comes the storm

[konjo78]

1. Matt Ryan
2. Tom Brady
3. Ben Roethlisberger
4. Aaron Rodgers
5. Derek Carr

Now you did it! Matty Ryan above the winningest QB of all time..hear comes the storm

All time rankings brady is ahead of him no doubt. But this is How i ranked the qbs going into week 2 of the season. If you want an all time top 10 qb list,
1. Brady*** (*** because the cheating that has taken place in the org)
2. Montana
3. Bradshaw
4. Manning
5. Favre

[Crimson's Ghost]

Are Super Bowls the best metric to judge a quarterback? Is Trent Dilfer better than Dan Marino?



I know some old time Steeler fans and even writers that have covered the team for years would generally say Roethlisberger is the best QB in Steelers history. Many have said Bradshaw was along for the ride on the 70 Super Bowl runs. Was he that good? I know he was good, but top 5 ever good?

[konjo78]

He has 2 superbowl MVPs in his 4 championships. He was able to lead one of the most balanced offenses in NFL history! Yes be did have an amazing defense but he also had a big clutch factor in big games.